The title says it all. There are many, many apps for listening to music these days. From Pandora, to Spotify and all points in between, selecting the best value for your money is getting harder and harder to do.
Basically, there are two types of music apps. First, there's Pandora and Slacker. They are free apps which allow you to select an artist or a style of music, and the app will create a radio station based on your selection. Like a radio station, the experience is passive: you can't call up specific tracks ... it plays what it thinks is music which you would like. That's why it's free! If you pay a small fee, both services have a premium version, but they don't allow you to select the songs (Slacker has a second tier of premium service which does allow you to select). The premium versions allow you to skip tracks you don't like and offer a higher quality sounding music stream, along with no commercials.
The other type of app allows you to call up any song in their library. There are many apps which fall into this category, the most famous being Spotify, MOG, Rdio, the premium version of Slacker, and Rhapsody. They all offer a free version of their service, but the user is limited as to how much music they can listen to. If you want to hear these services on your smartphone or tablet, they all charge $10 per month for unlimited listening.
So, Pandora and Slacker (basic) are programmable radio stations, and Spotify, etc. are like breaking into an record store and listening to whatever you want.
So which one is the best?
Well, that a great question!
Our mandate is to serve you, our loyal readers, and assist you sorting out the field and making observed and informed recommendations. The problem is, that takes a long time to do, and a lot of work! And, well, it's sweeps month on TV, so there's a lot of good viewing to do. And it's raining.
Fortunately, the folks over at iMore.com did the effort for us. And we are very happy to give you this link to that article.
They only compared Pandora, Slacker and Spotify, which is a little odd, since Spotify is a very different type of service from Pandora, but they did a great deal of research, and the article is a good read.
Update on Wednesday, May 2, 2012 at 9:31AM by
Bob Penn
Spotify for iPad was released today. It's long overdue and adds a nicely designed interface to this powerful service. Here's a good review of the iPad app: from CultofMac.com.
Update on Wednesday, May 2, 2012 at 9:33AM by
Bob Penn
BTW, if you want the Penn's Den recommendation as to which apps are the best, here we go:
Streaming app: Slacker, because it seems to offer a better music selection and more features for either free or for the low premium cost. Yet ... I still find myself using Pandora more. Old habits, I suppose.
On demand app: Spotify, particularly now that they've released the iPad app. Spotify has the best sound and the best selection. But their user interface has many, many problems, but they have been addressing them over the past few months. Best thing about Spotify: when you hit play, the music starts almost immediately. No other service has been able to do this. Worth it for that alone.
And don't forget about iTunes Match, the $25 service from Apple which puts your entire music library in the cloud. It's a great deal, and makes loading your music to your iPhone or iPad a thing of the past.